Compare two documents, then argue
TCF Canada writing task 3
Two short documents disagree on a social question. Part 1 sums up both views in your own words (40–60 words). Part 2 gives your position with arguments (80–120 words). This is the task most candidates lose points on.
- Word limit
- 120–180
- Part 1: summary (40–60) · Part 2: your opinion (80–120)
- Suggested time
- 25min
- Format
- Compare two opposing documents on a social question, then give your own position.
What examiners check
- Restate two points of view in your own words
- Compare
- Defend an opinion with arguments
Method
- 1Part 1: one sentence for the topic, one for each view, linked by « alors que », « au contraire » or « en revanche ». Never copy sentences from the documents.
- 2Part 2: state your position in the first sentence.
- 3Give two arguments with an example each, then a concession (« Il est vrai que… cependant… »).
- 4End with a one-sentence conclusion that answers the question.
Mistakes that cost a band
- Copying phrases from the documents in part 1: the examiner wants reformulation.
- Giving your opinion in part 1, or summarising again in part 2.
- Respecting the total but not each part's own limit.
Outline
Part 1: Les deux documents traitent de… Selon le premier,… Le second, au contraire, estime que…
Part 2: À mon avis,… D'abord,… Ensuite,… Il est vrai que… cependant… En conclusion,…A corrected example
All Task 3 topics
- Task 3Should remote work become the norm?Work
- Task 3Should students be allowed to use AI for homework?Studies
- Task 3Should we switch to a four-day week?Society
- Task 3Should social media be banned for under-15s?Technology
- Task 3Should phones be banned at school?Studies
- Task 3Should job ads show the salary?Work
- Task 3Should households pay for rubbish by weight?Environment
- Task 3Are video doctor appointments a good idea?Health
- Task 3Should older drivers be retested?Transport
- Task 3Self-checkouts: progress or a step back?Technology
- Task 3Should grandparents look after their grandchildren?Family
- Task 3Do children have too many activities?Leisure
- Task 3Dubbed or subtitled films?Culture
- Task 3Should short-term holiday rentals be limited?Housing
- Task 3Tipping or service included?Society
- Task 3Should tourist cities charge visitors an entry fee?Travel
Questions about Task 3
How many words for TCF Canada writing Task 3?
120 to 180 words (Part 1: summary: 40–60; Part 2: your opinion: 80–120). The paper counts 1 word = any group of characters between two spaces (« c'est-à-dire » = 1). Outside the limits, the task gets « A1 non atteint ».
How long should I spend on Task 3?
About 25 minutes. The 60-minute writing paper covers all three tasks, so the time you save on one goes to the others.
What do examiners check in Task 3?
Restate two points of view in your own words, Compare, Defend an opinion with arguments. Each is rated on the CEFR scale, and the paper is marked out of 20.
What writing mark do I need for NCLC 7?
10 out of 20 for the whole writing paper. IRCC's table: NCLC 7 = 10–11, NCLC 8 = 12–13, NCLC 9 = 14–15.